Vanished in Fleming Island: The Murder of Susan Malden

Prologue: A Morning Gone Wrong

Thursday morning, October 24th, 2019, began like any other in Fleming Island, Florida. The sun rose over the quiet, close-knit community, neighbors waved as they left for work, and Susan Malden’s friends expected to hear from her as usual. But that morning, something was off.

Phyllis Yates, Susan’s closest friend, dialed Susan’s cell phone. It went straight to voicemail. She tried again, and again. Nothing. Phyllis peered into Susan’s garage window and saw her car parked inside. The TV was on, but Susan was nowhere to be found.

“I hope nothing’s happened with her,” Phyllis told her husband, Dan, worry etched in her voice.

Susan Malden was a widow, well-loved and deeply involved in the Harbor Island neighborhood. She was a fixture in the local British club, a diehard Jacksonville Jaguars fan, and the kind of friend who called every Wednesday to check in. Her sudden disappearance sent shockwaves through the community.

Act I: The Search Begins

Phyllis and Dan drove to Susan’s house, using a spare key to let themselves in. They found the chain lock still engaged—Dan had to reach in and unlatch it. Inside, the house was eerily quiet. Susan’s bed was unmade, something she never did. Figurines on a table were askew, a picture frame was crooked, and water sat in the master bathroom sink.

Susan was meticulous about her home. Even with renovations underway, she never left things untidy. Her phone and laptop were missing. The home office, set up near the bathroom being remodeled, was in disarray.

Phyllis called the sheriff’s office. Deputies arrived, noting the odd details: the unmade bed, the missing electronics, the chain lock, and the subtle signs of disorder.

Detectives quickly ruled out the possibility that Susan had simply left on a trip without telling anyone. She was a creature of habit, always in touch with friends, and she’d missed a doctor’s appointment that day—something she’d never do.

Act II: A Life in Fleming Island

Susan Malden was 65, a British expatriate who’d made Fleming Island her home. Though she had no close family nearby, she was surrounded by friends. Outgoing, bubbly, and beloved, Susan was always involved—her absence was immediately felt.

Detectives interviewed neighbors and friends, piecing together Susan’s recent days. They learned about her ongoing home renovation and the contractor she’d hired: Cory Bindram.

Susan had paid Cory more than $12,000 up front to remodel her bathroom. He had demoed the room, tearing out sheetrock, the toilet, and cabinets, then left the job unfinished. Susan was frustrated. Every time she called Cory to finish the work, he had a new excuse—his sister died, he hurt his shoulder, he was out of town.

Susan kept meticulous records of every interaction, noting dates, times, and Cory’s excuses. She confided in Phyllis: Cory made her uncomfortable, complimenting her appearance and asking for a loan, even after she’d already paid him thousands.

Phyllis warned Susan to be cautious. Susan decided she’d confront Cory and demand her money back. If he refused, she’d involve the police.

Act III: The Last Encounter

Detectives tracked down Cory Bindram, a local contractor with a wife, two daughters, and a seemingly ordinary life. Cory’s wife, Cassidy, worked for CSX. Their children did well in school. On the surface, Cory was just another neighbor.

When detectives visited Cory, he claimed he’d last seen Susan on Thursday morning around 8 a.m. He described Susan as a difficult client, constantly changing her mind about tiles and fixtures. He said he’d refunded her $1,200—the total amount he claimed she’d paid him—and left her house with his tools.

Law enforcement knew from Phyllis and Susan’s records that the contract was for $12,000, not $1,200. Cory’s story didn’t add up.

Detectives pressed him. Cory maintained his innocence, saying he’d left Susan alive and well. But he was the last person to see her.

Act IV: Evidence in the Home

Investigators returned to Susan’s house, searching for clues. Sergeant Calhoun noticed a small drop of what appeared to be blood on the living room floor. Forensic analysts found more blood spatter on a nearby lampshade and detected signs of blood cleanup in front of the kitchen sink and cabinet.

The evidence suggested something violent had happened. Susan’s cell phone and laptop were missing. Her home office was disturbed.

Detectives obtained a warrant to search Cory’s storage unit, where he’d taken tools from Susan’s home. A cadaver dog alerted to the presence of human decomposition near a bag Cory had removed from Susan’s house.

Act V: Cory Under Surveillance

Investigators obtained Cory’s cell phone records. They found deleted messages from the day Susan vanished. Cory’s wife, Cassidy, revealed he had a substance abuse problem and had recently relapsed into cocaine use.

Cassidy also shared that Cory used the Life360 app on his phone to track his movements—a requirement after his previous drug issues. On the day Susan disappeared, Cory turned off the app for about an hour, precisely when he visited the Rosemary Hill landfill.

Video from Home Depot showed Cory buying contractor bags and quick-dry concrete that morning. He claimed he bought the concrete to build a step but said it got wet in his truck and he dumped it.

At the landfill, Cory’s truck weighed 300 pounds less upon leaving than when he arrived. The concrete bags and Susan’s weight matched the weight difference almost exactly.

Act VI: The Search for Susan

Detectives suspected Cory had disposed of Susan’s body at the landfill. Using cell tower data and Life360, they traced his movements. The landfill was massive, with thousands of tons of garbage. Law enforcement, assisted by the FBI, launched a search at the Chester Island landfill in Folkston, Georgia.

For nine days, searchers sifted through 7,600 tons of trash. On the tenth day, they found a piece of Susan’s lower jawbone. Dental records confirmed the match.

Nearby, they discovered a contractor bag containing the rest of Susan’s remains. The bag matched those Cory had purchased at Home Depot. Two fingernails recovered from the bag were sent for DNA analysis.

Act VII: The Case Builds

The DNA on one fingernail matched Susan. The other contained Susan’s DNA and that of an unknown male. No DNA from Cory was found on the nails.

The forensic pathologist determined Susan died from blunt force trauma and strangulation. Her hyoid bone was fractured at or near the time of death—a classic sign of homicide by strangulation.

Detectives reconstructed the crime: Cory confronted Susan at her home, struck her, and strangled her in the kitchen. He cleaned up the scene, loaded her body into his truck, and disposed of her at the landfill.

Act VIII: Cory’s Arrest and Trial

On January 31, 2020, Cory Bindram was arrested for Susan Malden’s murder. He was already incarcerated in Duval County Jail for fraud charges related to a stolen check.

Cory was charged with first-degree murder, burglary with assault or battery, and tampering with evidence. He pleaded not guilty. In Florida, a conviction could mean the death penalty.

The prosecution argued Cory had motive—money and fear of exposure. He killed Susan to avoid consequences.

The defense pointed to the lack of Cory’s DNA on Susan’s fingernails, arguing reasonable doubt. They suggested law enforcement had tunnel vision, focusing on Cory and ignoring other possibilities.

Act IX: The Trial Unfolds

The prosecution called Cassidy Bindram to testify. She described Cory’s drug use, his unusual behavior on the day Susan disappeared, and how he changed clothes and backed his truck into the garage—actions she’d never seen before.

Thomas Smith, an inmate who shared a cell block with Cory, testified that Cory confessed to killing Susan during an argument over payment. Smith said Cory described strangling Susan, feeling something break—a detail only the killer would know.

The defense attacked Smith’s credibility, noting his criminal record and potential motives to lie.

Nicholas Cutu, the crime lab technician, confirmed Cory’s DNA was not found on Susan’s fingernails. The defense argued this exonerated Cory.

After four days of testimony, closing arguments began. The prosecution insisted Cory was guilty. The defense asked the jury to find Cory not guilty due to reasonable doubt.

Act X: The Verdict and Aftermath

After just four hours of deliberation, the jury found Cory Bindram guilty on all counts: first-degree murder, burglary with assault or battery, and tampering with evidence.

The sentencing phase followed. Phyllis Yates delivered a victim impact statement, describing Susan as a blessing and a joy, a friend deeply missed.

Cory’s daughters wrote a letter asking for mercy, describing their father as loving and protective.

The jury voted seven to five in favor of the death penalty—but Florida law requires at least eight votes. Cory Bindram was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Epilogue: Lessons from Tragedy

Susan Malden’s murder shook Fleming Island. She was remembered as a vibrant, caring friend whose life was cut short by greed and violence. Her friends and neighbors mourned, but justice was served.

Detectives reflected on the case, emphasizing the importance of vetting individuals allowed into one’s home. The tragedy was a stark reminder that evil can hide in plain sight, and that meticulous investigation can bring answers, even when hope seems lost.

Susan’s legacy lives on in the memories of those who loved her. Her story is a testament to friendship, community, and the relentless pursuit of truth.

Act XI: Unraveling the Motives

As the dust settled after the verdict, the question lingered: Why? What drove Cory Bindram—a seemingly ordinary contractor, husband, and father—to commit such a brutal crime? Detectives poured over every detail, searching for answers.

Cory’s financial troubles had been mounting. The $12,000 Susan paid him was more than just a contract—it was a lifeline. But as Susan pressed for accountability, Cory’s world began to unravel. Cassidy, his wife, testified that his drug use had spiraled out of control, leading to erratic behavior and desperate decisions.

Friends and neighbors reflected on the warning signs. Some recalled Cory’s charm, others his volatility. Cassidy’s ultimatum—stay clean or lose your family—hung heavy over the trial. The prosecution argued that Susan’s demand for her money back was the final straw, igniting a confrontation that turned deadly.

Act XII: The Community Reacts

Fleming Island was shaken. For weeks, Susan’s disappearance dominated conversations, local news, and social media feeds. The British club, where Susan had been a beloved member, held vigils and fundraisers in her memory. Neighbors left flowers and notes outside her home, sharing stories of her kindness and generosity.

The sheriff’s office organized a town hall, inviting residents to discuss safety, vetting contractors, and supporting one another. Counselors were brought in to help friends and neighbors process their grief. The tragedy became a catalyst for change, prompting new community initiatives around safety and mental health.

Act XIII: The Search for Closure

Susan’s friends struggled to accept her loss. Phyllis Yates, who had sounded the alarm, found herself replaying the events of that fateful week. She remembered Susan’s meticulous nature, her laughter during Wednesday lunches, and her unwavering loyalty.

“I keep thinking if I’d called her one more time, maybe things would be different,” Phyllis told a local reporter. “But I know Susan. She was strong. She stood up for herself. And she deserves justice.”

The search for closure extended beyond the courtroom. Detectives continued to investigate Cory’s background, uncovering a history of deception and violence dating back to his teenage years. The community grappled with the reality that someone they thought they knew could harbor such darkness.

Act XIV: The Trial’s Ripple Effect

The trial itself became a focal point for the community. Local media covered every development, from the forensic breakthroughs to the emotional testimonies. The prosecution’s case was built on circumstantial evidence, but the details were compelling: the missing money, the deleted phone data, the concrete purchase, and the landfill records.

The defense fought hard, pointing to the lack of Cory’s DNA under Susan’s fingernails and suggesting alternate theories. But the jury was swayed by the totality of evidence—the timeline, the forensic findings, and Cory’s own inconsistencies.

After the sentencing, Susan’s friends and family gathered for a memorial service. The British club hosted a celebration of her life, sharing memories, photos, and Susan’s favorite recipes. Phyllis spoke about the importance of friendship, resilience, and community support.

Act XV: Lessons Learned

Detective Frier, who led the investigation, reflected on the case in a public statement. “You never know who you’re dealing with on a day-to-day basis,” he said. “It’s always important to vet individuals you allow into your home. Susan’s story reminds us to trust our instincts and look out for each other.”

The sheriff’s office launched a new program to educate residents on contractor fraud, background checks, and personal safety. Local organizations partnered with mental health advocates to provide resources for those struggling with addiction or emotional distress.

Susan’s legacy inspired change, ensuring that her story would help protect others in the future.

Act XVI: The Aftermath for Cory’s Family

While Susan’s loved ones mourned, Cory’s family faced their own reckoning. Cassidy and her daughters, Bailey and Megan, struggled to reconcile the man they loved with the actions he had taken. Their letter to the jury was heartfelt, pleading for mercy and describing Cory as a protective, loving father.

Cassidy spoke to reporters after the sentencing, urging others to seek help for loved ones battling addiction. “We lost Susan, and we lost Cory too,” she said. “Addiction destroys families. If you see the signs, don’t wait. Get help.”

The Bindram family retreated from public view, focusing on healing and rebuilding. The stigma of Cory’s actions lingered, but the community rallied around Cassidy and her daughters, offering support and understanding.

Act XVII: A Community Heals

Months passed, and Fleming Island began to heal. The British club planted a garden in Susan’s honor, a place for reflection and remembrance. Neighbors organized a neighborhood watch, sharing tips and resources.

Phyllis continued her Wednesday lunches, inviting new friends and keeping Susan’s memory alive. “She taught me to cherish every moment,” Phyllis said. “We can’t change the past, but we can honor Susan by living with kindness and courage.”

Detective Frier visited local schools, sharing Susan’s story and encouraging students to speak up if they felt unsafe. The case became a teaching moment, emphasizing the importance of community vigilance and compassion.

Act XVIII: The Broader Impact

Susan’s murder resonated beyond Fleming Island. News outlets across Florida covered the trial, sparking conversations about contractor fraud, elder abuse, and the dangers of substance abuse. Lawmakers proposed new regulations to protect homeowners from unscrupulous contractors.

Mental health organizations used Susan’s story to highlight the importance of early intervention. Support groups formed, offering counseling and resources for families affected by addiction and violence.

The Chester Island landfill search set a new standard for forensic investigations, proving that even in the most challenging circumstances, justice could prevail.

Act XIX: Reflections and Remembrance

On the anniversary of Susan’s disappearance, friends and neighbors gathered at the British club garden. Phyllis read a poem Susan had written, celebrating friendship and resilience. Candles were lit, and stories were shared.

Detective Frier attended, reflecting on the case’s impact. “Susan’s story changed us all,” he said. “It reminded us to never give up, to keep searching for the truth, and to stand together in the face of adversity.”

Cassidy and her daughters sent a message, thanking the community for their support. “We’re grateful for your kindness,” Bailey wrote. “We hope Susan’s legacy inspires others to seek help and cherish their loved ones.”

Act XX: Justice and Legacy

Susan Malden’s murder was a tragedy, but it also became a catalyst for change. Her meticulous nature, courage, and compassion inspired a community to come together, to heal, and to protect one another.

Cory Bindram will spend the rest of his life in prison, a reminder that justice, though sometimes slow, will prevail. Susan’s memory lives on in the garden, in the British club, and in the hearts of those who loved her.

Her story is a testament to the power of friendship, the importance of vigilance, and the enduring strength of community.

Epilogue: Moving Forward

As Fleming Island moves forward, Susan’s legacy endures. The British club continues its work, supporting local charities and fostering connections. The sheriff’s office remains vigilant, committed to protecting residents and pursuing justice.

Phyllis, Cassidy, and the entire community remember Susan not for the way she died, but for the way she lived—joyful, generous, and fiercely loyal.

If you or someone you know is struggling with addiction, violence, or loneliness, reach out. Help is available. Susan’s story reminds us all: trust your instincts, cherish your friends, and never be afraid to ask for help.